Cardinal Burke – Latest & Greatest Victim of the Dreaded “Francis Effect”?

Cardinal Burke – Latest & Greatest Victim of the Dreaded “Francis Effect”?

Cardinal Burke

As the impeccable prefect of the supreme tribunal of the apostolic signatura, [Cardinal Burke] is on the verge of being demoted to the purely honorary role of “patron” of an order of knighthood. At the behest of Pope Francis by Sandro Magister  

VATICAN CITY, September 17, 2014 – The “revolution” of Pope Francis in ecclesiastical governance is not losing its driving thrust. And so, as happens in every self-respecting revolution, the heads continue to roll for churchmen seen as deserving this metaphorical guillotine. In his first months as bishop of Rome, pope Bergoglio immediately provided for the transfer to lower-ranking positions of three prominent curial figures: Cardinal Mauro Piacenza, Archbishop Guido Pozzo, and Bishop Giuseppe Sciacca, considered for their theological and liturgical sensibilities among the most “Ratzingerian” of the Roman curia. Another whose fate appears to be sealed is the Spanish archbishop of Opus Dei Celso Morga Iruzubieta, secretary of the congregation for the clergy, destined to leave Rome for an Iberian diocese not of the first rank. But now an even more eminent decapitation seems to be on the way. The next victim would in fact be the United States cardinal Raymond Leo Burke, who from being prefect of the supreme tribunal of the apostolic signatura would not be promoted – as some are fantasizing in the blogosphere – to the difficult but prestigious see of Chicago, but rather demoted to the pompous – but ecclesiastically very modest – title of “cardinal patron” of the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, replacing the current head, Paolo Sardi, who recently turned 80.

If confirmed, Burke’s exile would be even more drastic than the one inflicted on Cardinal Piacenza, who, transferred from the important congregation for the clergy to the marginal apostolic penitentiary, nevertheless remained in the leadership of a curial dicastery. With the shakeup on the way, Burke would instead be completely removed from the curia and employed in a purely honorary position without any influence on the governance of the universal Church. This would be a move that seems to have no precedent. In the past, in fact, the title of “cardinalis patronus” of the knights of Malta, in existence since 1961, like the previous one of Grand Prior of Rome, has always been assigned to the highest ranking cardinals as an extra position in addition to the main one. This is what was done with cardinals Mariano Rampolla del Tindaro (appointed Grand Prior in 1896 while remaining secretary of state), Gaetano Bisleti (at the same time prefect of the congregation for Catholic education), Gennaro Granito Pignatelli (cardinal dean and bishop of Albano), Nicola Canali (governor of Vatican City), Paolo Giobbe (leader of the apostolic dataria), Paul-Pierre Philippe (until the age of 75 also prefect of the congregation for the Oriental Churches), Sebastiano Baggio (removed from the congregation for bishops but kept on as governor of Vatican City and camerlengo), Pio Laghi (until the age of 77 also prefect of the congregation for Catholic education).

Two separate cases are those of Cardinal Giacomo Violardo, who succeeded the 89-year-old Giobbe as patron at the age of 71, two months after receiving the scarlet at the end of long service in the curia, and of the outgoing Sardi, appointed pro-patron in 2009 at the age of 75 and made cardinal in 2010 after having been for many years the head of the office that writes pontifical documents. Above all, Sardi’s retirement would not be a compulsory act, since the age limit of 80 does not apply to positions outside of the curia. And in fact, with the exception of Paulo Giobbe, all of the aforementioned cardinal patrons went on to a better life “durante munere.”

Burke is 66 years old, and therefore still in his ecclesiastical prime. Ordained a priest by Paul VI in 1975, he worked at the apostolic signatura as an ordinary priest with John Paul II, who made him bishop of his native diocese of La Crosse, Wisconsin in 1993. It was again pope Karol Wojtyla who in 2003 promoted him as archbishop of the prestigious see, once cardinalate, of St. Louis, Missouri. Benedict XVI called him back to Rome in 2008, and made him a cardinal in 2010. With a very devout personality, he is also recognized as having the rare virtue of never having struck any deals to obtain ecclesiastical promotions or benefices. In the liturgical and theological camp, he is very close to the sensibilities of Joseph Ratzinger.

He has celebrated a number of times according to the ancient rite, even donning the “cappa magna,” as do cardinals George Pell and Antonio Cañizares Llovera, without being punished for this by Pope Francis. A great expert in canon law, and appointed to the apostolic signatura for this reason, he is not afraid to follow it to the most uncomfortable consequences. Like when, to the tune of articles of the Code – number 915 to be precise – he upheld the impossibility of giving communion to those politicians who stubbornly and publicly uphold the right to abortion, bringing the rebukes of two colleagues in the United States valued by Pope Francis, Sean Patrick O’Malley of Boston and Donald Wuerl of Washington.  (emphasis added)

Free in his judgments, he has been among the very few to make critical remarks on “Evangelii Gaudium,” pointing out that in his view it is orientational but not truly magisterial. And in view of the upcoming synod of bishops, he has repeatedly taken a stand against the ideas of Cardinal Walter Kasper – well known to be in the good graces of Pope Francis – in favor of communion for the divorced and remarried. The dicastery headed by Burke, eminently technical, recently accepted an appeal from the Franciscan Sisters of the Immaculate against a provision issued for them by the congregation for religious. A courageous move on the part of Burke, situated within the context of the punitive action undertaken by the Vatican congregation against one of the most substantial realities of Catholic traditionalism, an action that Pope Francis endorsed by approving in specific form the congregation’s decision to prevent the Friars of the Immaculate from celebrating the Mass according to the “Tridentine” rite.  (emphasis added)

It is only with this kind of pontifical approval, in fact, that a decree of the curia can overturn standing law, in this case the motu proprio of Benedict XVI “Summorum Pontificum.” It is difficult to identify among these episodes the ones that may have have had the greatest influence on the fate of Cardinal Burke. But it is easy to predict that his definitive downgrading will provoke both a tumultuous reaction within the traditionalist world, where Burke is seen as a hero, and a corresponding wave of jubilation in the opposite camp, where he is instead considered a bogeyman.

On the latter side it can be recalled that the “liberal” Catholic commentator Michael Sean Winters, in the “National Catholic Reporter” of November 26, 2013, had called for the head of Cardinal Burke as a member of the congregation for bishops, because of the nefarious influence, according to him, that he was exercising over episcopal appointments in the United States. On December 16, in effect, Pope Francis humiliated Burke by crossing him off from among the members of the congregation. To the hosannas of “liberal” Catholicism, not only in the United States. The pope certainly did not do so out of obedience to the wishes of the “National Catholic Reporter.” But now he seems right at the point of giving the go-ahead for the second and more grave demotion of one of the most untarnished personalities the Vatican curia knows.   Source


Those who remember the way Cardinal Burke caved in to the “liberal” bullies in Westminster by withdrawing at the last minute from his speaking engagement at the London Conference hosted by the orthodox group Pro Ecclesia et Pontifice, will be pleased to recall the details above of his later fearless confronting of the “liberal” elite. He is now paying the price, of course, if the reports of his “demotion” are, in fact, true.   We welcome your thoughts on this latest bombshell from Rome.


Comments (105)

  • Therese

    Second test as requested – and many thanks….

    September 23, 2014 at 10:13 am
    • editor

      You’re definitely organised now. When your first real comment (with avatar) appears, I’ll delete these tests.

      September 23, 2014 at 10:18 am
  • Margaret Mary

    This is Michael Matt’s reaction to the demotion of Cardinal Burke and the Cardinal Dolan scandal.

    September 23, 2014 at 10:35 am
  • Therese

    Thank you for posting this Margaret Mary.

    If I didn’t have Our Lord’s assurance that He would be with us until the end of time, I would be in flat despair. God have mercy on us all – especially on those traitorous/misguided churchmen who have led so many of the followers of His Holy Church into chaos and heresy. What I find most frightening and inexplicable is that through God’s grace I have not been misled, while so many much worthier people, have been. To those who have been given much, much is expected. Terrifying.

    September 23, 2014 at 3:35 pm
    • TLM

      Therese……’But by the Grace of God……there go I’. Yes, we have the Lord’s assurance…..and His word is more solid than gold. Amazingly as you said we have not fallen prey to deception…….but…..a short story about me. Years ago, I did for a time fall prey to erring prelates…..a friend of mine suggested I start praying the Rosary regularly……I did, and my eyes were opened wide! The Blessed Mother and her precious Rosary saved me, quite literally. As so did it my spouse. There are many more like us out there. Just yesterday, I read a terrific blog by a Catholic Convert. He is a real warrior for the truth of the Church, and as he put it, the truth is what led him into the Church, he will fight to the death for it. Needless to say, I am a real advocate of praying your daily Rosaries, as I also am for praying the Divine Mercy Chaplet. Praying that the Lord’s wonderful and endless Mercy will continue to poor out on us all, and may it also poor out on our poor deceived Prelates.

      September 23, 2014 at 4:28 pm
      • Therese


        I do believe that Our Lady is bringing us all together to enable us to receive consolation from each other in the wilderness in which we find ourselves. It’s a comfort to hear from others who see the truth so clearly, and who actually care.

        God bless you and your family and nice to have you “aboard”!

        September 23, 2014 at 4:39 pm
      • TLM

        Thank you Therese (my favorite saint btw….St. Therese the Little Flower)…..I am ever so glad to be here too! God Bless you and yours as well,, most abundantly.

        September 23, 2014 at 7:16 pm
  • Therese

    I saw Cardinal Dolan on EWTN the other day. He was explaining how so many of his parishes would have to cease to exist – but not to worry, this is a GOOD thing! Yes, like my own bishop, he expounds that we must go forward with “outrageous hope”.

    Outrageous is the word.

    September 23, 2014 at 3:39 pm
    • Michaela


      I couldn’t agree more – absolutely outrageous to think that any good can come from a shrinking Church when Our Lord commanded us to spread the Faith across the world.

      BTW, I love your avatar!

      September 23, 2014 at 9:11 pm
  • Therese

    Thanks Michaela. It is my favourite picture of Our Lady – both She and the baby Jesus have such beautiful faces and expressions. I have a copy hanging in my home and would love to know who painted it.

    September 23, 2014 at 10:01 pm
  • editor


    Well it sure wasn’t me. My artistic skills are second only to my cooking. The most commonly heard sound in our house is not me rattling my rosary beads but the smoke alarm going off!

    September 23, 2014 at 11:11 pm
    • Therese


      Don’t tell me you haven’t got any of St Delia’s cook books? You’d be a domestic goddess in no time at all….

      September 26, 2014 at 5:45 pm
      • editor


        Once I discovered that she is an advocate of women’s ordination I lost interest in her books. Anyway, I couldn’t find a single recipe for boiling eggs in any of them 😉

        September 26, 2014 at 10:41 pm
  • Linda

    Did anyone watch Raymond Arroyo on EWTN this week? Was the silence regarding Cardinal Burke as obvious to anyone else as it was to me? There was a brief reference to “the book” written by Cardinal Burke, Cardinal Pell and others, but, there was no mention at all regarding the possible demotion of Cardinal Burke by Pope Francis. To Mr. Arroyo’s credit, he did question some of Cardinal Kasper’s remarks. Mind you, I have great respect for EWTN, the orthodoxy of the majority of their program and the clergy. Father Mitch Pacwa is a most faithful and well-educated Jesuit. However, this ‘news cast’ seemed to ignore this serious issue, in my opinion.

    September 26, 2014 at 3:15 pm
    • editor


      Christopher Ferrara has written a book about EWTN, entitled EWTN: A Network Gone Wrong. It is worth checking out.

      September 26, 2014 at 3:21 pm
    • TLM

      In my opinion too Linda. Yes I watched it and yes it was so very obviously MISSING INFORMATION. Important information.

      September 26, 2014 at 5:39 pm
  • Therese


    It makes you wonder what they’re scared of, doesn’t it?

    September 26, 2014 at 5:47 pm
  • Therese

    Just had a quick read of Editor’s link to Christopher Ferrara’s book. I’ve stopped wondering.

    September 26, 2014 at 5:50 pm

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: